Editor’s note: This case is for paying subscribers. Free subscribers will see a paywall.

A 53-year-old man presented to the ED by EMS as a stroke activation.

He had left hemibody paralysis and neglect.

CT ruled out intracranial hemorrhage.

He received a rapid neurology consult during the stroke activation.

tPA was given and the patient was taken to the ICU.

Imaging confirmed a large right MCA stroke.

The next morning, the patient had declined.

During ICU rounds, a consult was put in for neurosurgery.

The ICU staffed noted that his left-side deficits had not improved.

They also grew concerned that he had now developed right-side deficits.

It became clear that the patient had undergone a left-side craniectomy and anterior temporal lobectomy, instead of the right side.

The records do not describe who realized the mistake, but regardless, the neurosurgeon was notified and returned to the bedside.

logo

Subscribe to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber to read the rest of this lawsuit.

Subscribe Now

Benefits of subscribing:

  • become a better anesthesiologist
  • get biweekly new cases straight to your inbox
  • avoid lawsuits by reading anesthesiology malpractice cases
  • improve your medicolegal expertise

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Evidence Based Practice6 months ago

"They actually had the entire case stricken from the court records shortly after it settled, but I stumbled across it before it was removed."

I am torn on whether this should be allowed and whether you have an ethical and moral duty (in this case) to remove the redacted portions to educate the public.

On one hand, no one wants a black mark. This case is likely one of the blackest marks your professional reputation can carry. I am empathetic towards those individuals involved in this because the 2nd victim effect is very much a real phenomenon.

On the other hand, this was a horrible outcome. Is the public entitled to be aware of these people?

Avatar

Eric FunkAuthor5 months ago

I did have the same thought. Ultimately I decided that it was acceptable to publish it because I redacted all the names out of the case. I felt like it would be over the line if I had blasted the physicians names (or patient) all over the internet, but protecting their privacy felt like the right thing to do, and let me strike the balance of education and protection.

Avatar

Walter Quiroga2 months ago

If we adopt a “just culture” approach, then maintaining confidentiality is the right thing to do. In other words, we focus on the errors, learn from them, and use the lesson to carry our work forward.

If we disclose who was involved here, what can that achieve, other than publicly ruining their livelihood? If protection of the public is the genuine motivation for disclosure, there exist appropriate mechanisms for this protection, e.g. disclosure to credentialing committees, disclosure to state medical boards.

If education of the public is desired goal, what exactly is the nature of the lesson for the public? Beyond learning to be active participants in their own medical care (which I doubt is possible during critical illness), how are they expected to know what to do with the information from this suit?

Avatar

Evidence Based Practice2 months ago

I think you make a good point regarding naming the individuals here and I'm willing to concede that point. I will say that I do not know if I believe (or agree with) your faith in the relative usefulness of the paternalistic structures that are medical board of examiners.

Perhaps a more useful middle ground here would be naming the institution that this occurred at. Because, presumably, the pattern witnessed above seems to be indicative of a pattern of normalized deviance/drift (i.e. the timeout process being a checkmark rather than a sacred action) which is certainly a much more impactful issue as it touches not 1 life but multiple thousands of lives each day.