Editor’s note: This case is for paying subscribers. Free readers will see a paywall.

A 39 year old healthy woman underwent a robotic myomectomy for the removal of 2 fibroids.

Post operatively she suffered bilateral numbness from her wrist down to her 4th and 5th digits, with the right worse than left.

She sued her surgeon, anesthesiologist, and the hospital for the following:

Here is the purported negligence of the anesthesiologist:

The total anesthetic time for her procedure was 2 hours and 10 minutes.

The surgery and anesthetic were otherwise uneventful.

Become a better anesthesiologist by reviewing medical malpractice cases.

Paying subscribers get access to the entire archive and a new biweekly case.

She first called the surgeon’s office 1 week after her surgery to report these symptoms, and was sent to a neurologist who performed an EMG.

After a diagnosis of cubital tunnel syndrome she saw a hand surgeon.

A cubital brace was prescribed but not tolerated.

She underwent a cubital tunnel release and ulnar nerve transposition.

At 1 year follow up she had improved enough to return to work as a teacher, but still suffered from continued neuropathy symptoms.

The following is the OR documentation from the anesthesiologist and nursing staff concerning patient positioning.

An anesthesiologist was hired as a defense expert.

logo

Subscribe to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber to read the rest of this lawsuit.

Subscribe Now

Benefits of subscribing:

  • become a better anesthesiologist
  • get biweekly new cases straight to your inbox
  • avoid lawsuits by reading anesthesiology malpractice cases
  • improve your medicolegal expertise

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Danesthesia .1 year ago

Interesting case - thanks for your presentation and analysis. Curious that the prefabricated checklist "checked off" by the anesthesiologist only lists "ulnar nerve precautions" - I wonder how the defense would have looked if the patient claimed any other nerve injury.

I may need to add a stock phase about "upper extremity nerve injury precautions taken as part of positioning" to my anesthesia record

Avatar

J CAuthor1 year ago

I do have a fair amount of positioning injury cases. I’ll look for an upper extremity non ulnar nerve and we can see how the documentation holds up!